What to look for · Christmas

What to buy a baby for their first Christmas, by age, and what to tell the grandparents who ask

By The Scoutalist team Checked October 21, 2026

Scoutalist is reader-supported. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It does not change what we recommend, and several options on our pages earn us nothing. Full disclosure.

Short answer

A baby under one needs almost nothing and gets everything. Buy four things: a few board books, one open-ended toy for their age (a soft ball, stacking cups, a wooden ring stacker), clothes in the next two sizes, and the one keepsake with the year on it. When relatives ask, send them that list and the AAP's rule: every toy and every part bigger than the baby's mouth, no button batteries, no magnets, no ribbons on the stuffed animal. The thing you'll actually want in January is a frozen meal. Say that too.

People will ask. By the second week of December, every grandparent, aunt and coworker wants to know what to get the baby, and if you don’t have an answer they’ll get the giant light-up thing with forty small parts and a coin battery. Here’s the answer, by age, and the text to send.

Under six months

They can’t sit up, can’t hold much, and are happiest looking at a face. Buy board books with high-contrast pictures, one soft rattle bigger than their fist, and clothes in the 9- and 12-month sizes. That’s the list. Every gift that says “6m+” on the label goes in the closet until six months, per the AAP’s rule that the age on the label is a safety line, not a reading level.

One thing nobody tells you: hanging crib toys, the mobile and the crib gym, come down the day the baby first pushes up on hands and knees, or at five months, whichever’s first. The AAP is exact about that. The mobile gift from the shower is a four-month gift.

Six to nine months

Sitting, grabbing, chewing everything. This is the stacking-cups age. A soft textured ball. A board book with flaps they can’t tear. A rubber-ish teether that’s one piece. Bath toys with no hole in the bottom (the ones with a hole grow mold inside).

Everything passes the AAP’s one test: every toy and every part bigger than the baby’s mouth. “Think LARGE” is their phrase.

Nine to twelve months

Crawling, pulling up, dropping things on purpose. A wooden ring stacker. A shape sorter with big shapes. A push toy for the kid who’s standing. A board book with a mirror in it. And a set of plain wooden blocks, which they’ll use until they’re seven.

The box the toy came in is the better toy. Keep one big one.

Clothes, two sizes up

The gift parents want and nobody buys. A baby born in June is wearing 12-month clothes at Christmas and 18-month by March. Buy for March. Pajamas with a full-length zipper, socks in bulk, one nice outfit for Easter. Nobody has ever been sad to open a stack of 18-month pajamas in December.

The keepsake

One dated ornament with the year. A handprint on cardstock you make yourself, the way the Halloween page does it, cut into a circle and hung with a ribbon. A photo book of the first six months. One of these, not all three.

What to tell the relatives

Text this, two weeks out, to everyone who asks and everyone who doesn’t:

“Here’s what she’d actually use: board books, a soft ball or stacking cups, clothes in 12- and 18-month sizes, and that’s it. No button batteries, no magnets, nothing with small parts (the pediatricians’ rule is everything bigger than her mouth). If you want to do something bigger, a zoo membership or the college fund. And honestly, a frozen lasagna in January.”

The AAP’s holiday list backs every line: simple over electronic, don’t overspend, no button batteries or magnets, think about what a digital gift is for before accepting one. Most relatives are relieved to be told.

When the wrong thing arrives anyway

It will. Three things, before it reaches the baby, from the AAP: check every piece against the mouth, cut any ribbon or string off the stuffed animal, and tape or screw shut every battery door. The button-battery page is why that last one isn’t optional: a swallowed coin battery starts burning within hours and the only answer is the ER. Then the 3+ toy goes on a high shelf with a note on it, and comes down at three.

Open the baby's gifts on the 26th, on the floor, one at a time, with the camera on. On the 25th the baby is being held by eleven people and doesn't want a ring stacker. On the 26th, in pajamas, with nobody watching, the stacking cups get a full twenty minutes, and that's the video.

What to skip

Anything with a coin battery, or with a door a fingernail opens. Anything labeled 3+ “because they’ll grow into it”; they will, in three years, and until then it’s small parts on the floor. Stuffed animals with pellets inside or a ribbon on the neck. And more than four gifts. A baby with four gifts has a great Christmas; a baby with fourteen has fourteen boxes, which, to be fair, is also a great Christmas.

What to look for, and where

Each button opens the store's current listings and today's prices.

  1. Board books, a stack

    The one gift every age under one uses, chews, and keeps. Thick pages, high contrast for the youngest, flaps for the older ones.

    Find on Amazon Search eBay Or the library's used-book sale, where board books are a quarter

    Affiliate links.

  2. A soft ball

    Rolled, grabbed, chewed, thrown at the dog. Bigger than the baby's mouth by a mile, no parts, washable.

    Affiliate links.

  3. Stacking cups

    Six months to three years from one set. Bath toy, sand toy, the thing that gets knocked over four hundred times. Nothing to swallow.

    Affiliate links.

  4. A wooden ring stacker

    For the 9-to-12-month crowd. Rings too big to choke on, a post to put them on, a year of use. Check the label says no small parts.

    Affiliate links.

  5. Clothes in the next two sizes

    The gift the parents want and nobody buys. A baby born in June is in 12-month clothes by Christmas and 18-month by spring. Buy spring.

    Affiliate links.

  6. A dated first-Christmas ornament

    The keepsake. Handmade sellers put the name on; order early, they ship slow in December.

    Affiliate links.

Questions parents ask

What do I tell relatives who want to buy something big?

A membership (the zoo, the children's museum), a contribution to the college account, or a month of the diaper subscription. The AAP's holiday advice is to not overspend on gifts; the baby won't know, and the parents remember a zoo membership long after they've forgotten a ride-on toy that's in the garage.

Are the light-up, singing toys bad?

The AAP says toys don't need to be electronic and that the simple ones suit a baby better. The specific worry is the battery: many run on a coin battery behind a door that opens with a fingernail, and a swallowed one is an emergency. If one arrives, tape the door shut before it reaches the baby, and put the big-box version on the shelf until the age on the label.

What about a stuffed animal?

Fine, with the AAP's two checks: no bean-like pellets inside, and cut off any ribbon or string around the neck. And nothing stuffed goes in the crib; the AAP's crib rule is a flat sheet and the baby, nothing else, for the first year.

Sources

American Academy of Pediatrics guidance on toy safety, button batteries, choking, and holiday gifts; four first-time parents interviewed in September and October 2026 on what they'd want from a page. Products are not hands-on tested.

First published October 21, 2026. Last checked October 21, 2026.