Ideas · Thanksgiving

Non-traditional Thanksgiving ideas for families: Friendsgiving, the turkey trot, a day outside, and the honest version of volunteering

By The Scoutalist team Checked October 10, 2026

Scoutalist is reader-supported. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It does not change what we recommend, and several options on our pages earn us nothing. Full disclosure.

Short answer

You don't owe anyone a turkey. Friendsgiving is a potluck with the people who are actually around; the host does the main dish and everybody else brings one thing in a dish they can carry. A turkey trot gives the morning a shape and gets everyone outside before the eating. A fire pit, a hike with a thermos of soup, or pancakes at noon all count. If you want to volunteer, sign up for a shift in December or January, not Thanksgiving morning; food banks say that's when they actually need you. Pick the one your family will want to do again next year. That's what makes it a tradition.

Somebody in your family doesn’t want to do it the old way this year. Maybe it’s you. The in-laws are in two states, the one aunt who hosted isn’t hosting, the kids are small and a four-hour drive for a three-hour dinner isn’t a day anyone wants. Or you’ve just always wanted to eat pie outside.

None of these ideas is less of a Thanksgiving. One first-time dad told us his family has “skipped things for other holidays but it was to include other family’s traditions as well. It went well, but we are making our own traditions as we go.” The ones that stick are the ones your kids ask about in October.

Friendsgiving

A meal with the people who are around, on or near Thanksgiving. Merriam-Webster’s first record of the word is 2007, which means the people who started it are now the parents reading this.

The version that works with kids:

The host does the main. Turkey, ham, a giant pan of lasagna, nobody cares. One big thing, done by the house with the oven.

Everyone else brings one dish, in a dish they can carry. Not “I’ll bring something.” A dish, named, in a text thread, a week ahead, so there aren’t four green bean casseroles and no rolls. The insulated carrier is the thing that makes a hot dish arrive hot.

It’s on the weekend, not Thursday. The Saturday before or the Saturday after. Thursday stays with whoever claims it, and nobody has to pick.

The kids’ table is the floor. A blanket in the living room, paper plates, a movie on low. Friendsgiving kids eat in forty seconds and then play; set up the room for that and nobody fights about chairs.

Food out on the counter for the whole afternoon runs into the USDA’s two-hour rule. The buffet goes out, people eat, and two hours later the host boxes what’s left and the pies come out. Nobody notices and nobody gets sick on Sunday.

The turkey trot morning

Thanksgiving is the biggest day of the year for running races in the U.S. Running USA’s last published count had nearly a million finishers across 726 races on Thanksgiving Day 2016, and called it the sport’s most popular race day. That number is old; we couldn’t find a newer one from them. The races haven’t gotten smaller.

As a family thing, a turkey trot does three jobs. It gets everyone out of the house and cold and hungry by ten. It gives the morning a shape, so the kids aren’t asking “when’s dinner” at 9 a.m. And it’s the same place, same morning, every year, which is the whole definition of a tradition.

Check the race page for a kids’ run and the stroller rule; most local ones have both. Nobody’s timing you. Sign up in October; the local ones sell out, and the shirt is the souvenir the kids wear all winter.

It’s also fine to try it once and stop. One dad told us his family did a turkey trot “in the past but we have skipped out on that because quickly found out that we are not runners lol.” A tradition that doesn’t take is information, not failure; the kids still got the shirt.

If you’re hosting too, the trot happens while the turkey’s in the oven and one adult stays home to watch it. The hosting page has the morning timed out.

Outside

A fire pit in the yard, camp chairs in a circle, chili in a pot and pie on a cutting board. Or a trail you know, a thermos of soup per person, sandwiches made from whatever you’d have roasted, and the overlook as the table. Or a tailgate at the park with the back of the car open.

What makes it work is treating it as the plan, not the backup. Tell everyone the week before: Thanksgiving’s outside this year, dress for it. Pack hand warmers for the kids and a second pair of socks per child. A fire pit gets three feet of clear ground around it and a bucket of water beside it, and a kid under five gets a hand held near it.

If a baby’s coming along, the first-fall-outing page has the layering and the car-seat rule.

Breakfast Thanksgiving

Pancakes at noon. Or a big egg bake, bacon, cinnamon rolls, and a pie because it’s still Thanksgiving. For a family with a toddler who melts down at five o’clock, moving the meal to midday fixes the day. The kids eat breakfast food happily, the adults have the afternoon free, and the parade’s on in the background while you cook.

The Thursday-night dinner becomes leftover sandwiches on the couch, which, if you’re honest, was always the best part.

The restaurant

Somebody cooks, somebody else does the dishes, and the family sits at one table for two hours with nobody getting up. Book it in October. Bring crayons; a Thanksgiving restaurant is slow by design. The tradeoff is the leftovers, which is why some families do the restaurant Thursday and cook a small turkey Friday just for the sandwiches.

Volunteering, the honest version

Everyone’s instinct is to serve a meal on Thanksgiving morning. The food banks’ answer is kinder than you’d expect and not what you’d expect. The Idaho Foodbank told a local station it would rather not get a flood of volunteers on the day itself: a one-day surge is hard to use, and what they need is people in December, January, and the spring. “We really do need volunteers all year round,” their development manager said. Call yours before you show up; the answer may be the same.

So: sign the family up for a January shift. Feeding America’s search tool finds the food bank near you, and most of them list their own shifts. Pick a Saturday, put it on the calendar on Thanksgiving Day, and tell the kids that’s the Thanksgiving thing. If you want the day itself to count for something, bring a bag of canned goods to the trot; a lot of races have a collection bin at the start.

A kid who stocks shelves in January learns something a kid who watched adults ladle gravy in November didn’t.

Two Thanksgivings

The split-family version: Thursday with one side, Saturday with the other, or Thursday at home and the weekend on the road. The thing to decide is which one is the turkey and which one is the pizza. Trying to do two full dinners two days apart is how parents end up crying in a Costco parking lot. One real meal, one easy one, both on the calendar, and the kids learn that the holiday is the people, not the bird.

Whatever you pick, take the same photo every year. Same spot, same arrangement: the finish line, the fire pit, the front steps. The first one is a photo. The fifth one is the tradition.

What to skip

A potluck with no list; you’ll get four desserts and no vegetable. Volunteering on the morning itself when the shelter didn’t ask for you. Two full dinners in three days. An outdoor Thanksgiving nobody was told to dress for. And anything on the AAP’s choking list on a trail or a blanket, where a toddler eating a whole grape is thirty yards from the nearest adult who’d notice.

What to look for, and where

Each button opens the store's current listings and today's prices.

  1. An insulated casserole carrier

    The Friendsgiving essential. A hot dish stays hot across town, and the lid stays on in the trunk. The one with a pocket for the serving spoon is the one you want.

    Affiliate links.

  2. A big drink dispenser

    Cider for the kids, something else for the adults, two spigots and nobody asks you for a refill all afternoon. Works on a porch rail or a tailgate.

    Affiliate links.

  3. Folding camp chairs

    For the fire pit, the tailgate, the park, or the overflow in the living room. Buy the kind with a cup holder; you will be holding a plate.

    Find on Amazon Search eBay Or ask every car to bring their own; it's the first thing people forget and the easiest to carry

    Affiliate links.

  4. A wide-mouth food thermos

    Soup or chili on a trail, still hot at the overlook. One per person, filled with boiling water first for five minutes and then dumped, so the food goes in hot and stays that way.

    Affiliate links.

  5. A portable fire pit

    The center of an outdoor Thanksgiving. The smokeless kind keeps the kids from crying and the neighbors from calling. Three feet of clear ground around it and a bucket of water next to it.

    Affiliate links.

Questions parents ask

Is it rude to skip the family dinner for a Friendsgiving?

It's a calendar problem, not a loyalty one. Most families do Friendsgiving the weekend before or the Saturday after, and the Thursday stays Thursday. If Thursday is the one you're skipping, call before, not after.

What do the kids do at a turkey trot?

Most local trots have a kids' fun run and allow strollers in the 5K; the race page says. Nobody's timing anybody. Dress them for the weather, not the race; they'll be standing around at the start for twenty minutes.

Can we really not volunteer on Thanksgiving Day?

You can, and some places take walk-ins. But the Idaho Foodbank's answer is that a one-day crowd is hard to use and the real need is December through spring. Book a January shift as a family, and bring a bag of canned goods on Thanksgiving if you want the day itself to count.

Sources

Merriam-Webster on the word Friendsgiving; Running USA's count of Thanksgiving Day races; the Idaho Foodbank on holiday volunteering as reported by KTVB; Feeding America's volunteer page; USDA guidance on leftovers; American Academy of Pediatrics guidance on choking; three first-time parents interviewed in October 2026. Products are not hands-on tested.

First published October 8, 2026. Last checked October 10, 2026.