Ideas · Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving traditions worth starting this year: the signed tablecloth, the recorded interview, and six more that get better every year

By The Scoutalist team Checked October 10, 2026

Scoutalist is reader-supported. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It does not change what we recommend, and several options on our pages earn us nothing. Full disclosure.

Short answer

Start one thing this year that you'll do again next year. The two that pay off most: a plain cotton tablecloth everyone signs and dates with a fabric marker, brought out every Thanksgiving until it's full of twenty years of handwriting, and a recorded conversation with the oldest person in the room, which StoryCorps' Great Thanksgiving Listen will help you do and keep. Add the same photo in the same spot every year. Keep the list to three traditions at most. The ones that last are the ones a seven-year-old can run.

The traditions your kids will carry into their own houses aren’t the ones you planned. They’re the ones that happened twice and then nobody could stop. One first-time dad, a few weeks from his daughter’s arrival, put it the way most new parents feel it: “we are making our own traditions as we go.” Here are the ones that tend to stick, and why.

The signed tablecloth

A plain cotton tablecloth. A pack of fabric markers. Every person at the table signs it and writes the year. Little kids trace a hand. Somebody writes what they’re thankful for, somebody draws a turkey, somebody writes the thing that happened that year that you’ll have forgotten by the next one.

Then it gets washed, folded, and put away until next Thanksgiving, when it comes out and everybody reads last year first.

Twenty years in, it’s a document. The handwriting changes. The hand that got traced in 2026 signs in cursive in 2036. The people who aren’t at the table anymore are still on the cloth. We couldn’t find a parenting or pediatric source for any of this; it’s just what families who’ve done it will tell you, usually while pointing at a corner.

Set the marker the way its package says, usually with an iron, before the first wash. If a tablecloth feels like too much, a roll of butcher paper over the table does the same thing and gets kept in a tube.

The recorded interview

One dad told us his family’s Thanksgiving tradition is that “we always share old stories of those who are no longer with us.” That’s most families. The oldest person at the table knows things nobody else in the room knows, and nobody’s asked. Thanksgiving is the one afternoon a year when they’re sitting still, in a room with the grandkids, with nothing to do between dinner and pie.

StoryCorps’ Great Thanksgiving Listen is built for exactly this. Since 2015 it’s asked people to record a conversation with an elder, a mentor or someone they admire over Thanksgiving weekend, using their free app on a phone, and to upload it to the StoryCorps Archive at the Library of Congress’s American Folklife Center. Hundreds of thousands of people have. The keyword for finding other families’ recordings, and for yours to be found, is TheGreatListen.

The rules that matter for a family: anyone 13 or older can participate, and anyone under 18 needs a parent’s consent to make an archive account. So a twelve-year-old can ask the questions while a parent holds the phone and owns the account, and a teenager can run the whole thing.

The questions that work are the plain ones. Where did you grow up. What was your first job. How did you meet. What was Thanksgiving like when you were my age. What do you want people to remember about you. Twenty minutes is plenty; forty is a gift.

If the archive part feels like too much, skip it. Record it on the phone’s voice memo app and keep it. The point is the conversation and the file. The archive is a bonus, and a good one.

The same-spot photo

One photo, same place, same arrangement, every year. The front steps. The big chair. The end of the table with the turkey carcass. Kids in order of age, left to right, so the lineup shifts as people are born and grow.

Prop the phone on a tripod, set the timer, and take three. The first year it’s a snapshot. The fifth year it’s the thing everyone looks for.

The gratitude jar

A jar on the counter from November 1. All month, anyone can drop in a slip of paper with one thing they’re thankful for. Kids who can’t write yet tell a parent, who writes it down and signs the kid’s name.

At Thanksgiving dinner, between the plates and the pie, the jar gets emptied and read aloud, one slip at a time, by whoever’s youngest and reading. The AAP’s November newsletter puts it plainly: kids learn gratitude by watching, and family meals are where thanks gets said out loud. The jar is a way to make that happen without a speech. “The dog” will be in there eleven times. So will one thing that makes a grown-up go quiet.

The thankful pumpkin is the one-day version of this, for houses where a jar on the counter for a month wouldn’t survive.

The thankful turkey

The same idea as the jar, for a house with little kids. A paper turkey body on the fridge on November 1, and a construction-paper feather added every day with one thing written on it, until there’s a bird with thirty feathers on Thanksgiving morning. A first-time dad described exactly this as the tradition he wants to start: “I want a thanksgiving turkey that shows the things we are thankful for each day. It adds reason to the season.” The kids draw the feathers, a parent writes what they say, and the turkey comes down and goes in the keepsake box with the year on the back.

The extra chair

Two of the three parents we asked “what does your family still talk about” told us a version of the same story, and neither was about food.

One dad: “Our neighborhood used to bring in marines from Camp Lejeune for the day and you get to have 2-3 of the marines hangout with you all day. We still talk about how awesome that was because it made the marines’ year because they weren’t able to go back home to their families for the holiday so we took them in for 1 day as our own.”

One mom: the Thanksgiving her family still tells is “the first Thanksgiving that my cousin joined us,” the year her aunt adopted her at three.

The tradition under both is a chair at the table for somebody who wasn’t going to have one. A neighbor on their own. The coworker whose family’s three states away. A kid’s college roommate who couldn’t fly home. Military bases near a lot of towns run programs that match service members with local families for the day; ask the base’s family-readiness office in early November. The kids set the extra place, and twenty years later it’s the Thanksgiving they talk about.

The neighbor plate

The smaller version of the extra chair. Before anyone sits down, one plate gets made up and walked next door, to the neighbor who’s alone, or the one who’s working, or the one who’s new. A kid carries it. That’s the whole tradition, and the kid who carries it at six will drive it at sixteen.

Use a container you don’t need back. And the two-hour rule applies to the neighbor’s plate too, so it goes over hot and goes in their fridge, not on their porch.

The kids’ job that’s always theirs

Pick one Thanksgiving job per kid and make it theirs every year. The place cards. Pulling the wishbone. Reading the jar. Carrying the neighbor plate. Taking the photo. A job that’s yours at five and still yours at twenty-five is how a kid knows the holiday needs them. The kids’-jobs page has the list by age.

The Friday after

Pie for breakfast on Friday, in pajamas, before anyone talks about shopping. Leftover pie keeps fine in the fridge overnight. It’s a ten-minute tradition and the kids will defend it with their lives.

Or the bigger version. One mom from the coast told us the tradition she’s keeping from her own childhood is the “Friday after Thanksgiving oyster roast. Keeping because it’s yummy and something everyone always looks forward to.” Thursday is the meal you inherit. Friday is the one you get to invent, and it’s often the one the kids like better.

The far-away call

For the family that isn’t at the table: one video call, at a set time, with the phone propped where everyone can lean in. Three minutes per person, the kids first. Or the lower-effort version: one group text, everyone sends one photo and one thankful thing, same thread every year, so the thread becomes the record.

Write the year and the tradition on the inside of the tablecloth hem, or on a card in the jar: "Started 2026." Twenty years from now somebody will ask when it began, and nobody will remember, and the hem will.

The one you set down for a while

A tradition you stop for a few years is still a tradition. One dad told us the one he’s dropping this year is deer hunting, “(at the moment) because I have a 4 month old and I will like to be around him the whole day.” Say that out loud to the people who’ll miss you at the deer stand, and put the year you plan to come back on the tablecloth. The kids will hold you to it.

What to skip

Starting five traditions at once; start one, maybe two. Anything that needs the adults to run it; the ones that last are the ones a seven-year-old can own. Recording Grandpa without asking. And a tablecloth you haven’t tested the marker on; write the year on a corner of the back first, wash it, and see if it stays. You get one shot at the first year.

What to look for, and where

Each button opens the store's current listings and today's prices.

  1. A plain white or cream cotton tablecloth

    The one that gets signed. Plain cotton is what fabric markers are made for; check the marker's label for what it sets on. Buy it a size bigger than the table so it still fits when the table has a leaf in it in ten years.

    Find on Amazon Search eBay Or a roll of butcher paper taped to the table, which gets kept in a tube instead of a drawer

    Affiliate links.

  2. Fabric markers

    Fine-tip, a few colors, the kind that sets with an iron. One pack lasts years because it comes out one day a year.

    Affiliate links.

  3. A small tripod for a phone

    For the interview and the yearly photo. Hands free, same height every year, and nobody's cropped out of the family shot because they were holding the camera.

    Affiliate links.

  4. A big glass jar

    The gratitude jar. It sits on the counter from November 1 and gets read at the table. A mason jar does it; a jar with a wide mouth means little hands can get the slips in.

    Find on Amazon Or the pickle jar, washed; it's a tradition, not a decoration

    Affiliate links.

  5. Takeout containers for the neighbor plate

    The plate that goes next door. Containers you don't need back, so the tradition doesn't come with a chore.

    Affiliate links.

Questions parents ask

Our kids are little. Which one do we start with?

The tablecloth. A two-year-old's handprint traced in marker is the first entry, and they'll find it themselves when they're twelve. The interview can wait until there's a kid old enough to ask questions, around eight or nine, and the StoryCorps archive part starts at thirteen.

What if the oldest relative doesn't want to be recorded?

Ask once, then leave the phone in your pocket and have the conversation anyway. Some people warm up after a year of watching a grandchild interview somebody else. Some never do, and the conversation still happened.

How many traditions is too many?

Three. One everyone does (the tablecloth), one that takes ten minutes (the photo, the jar), and one that's a project (the interview). Past three, you're running a program, and the kids can tell.

Sources

StoryCorps' Great Thanksgiving Listen page; American Academy of Pediatrics newsletter guidance on gratitude and family meals; USDA guidance on leftovers; three first-time parents interviewed in October 2026. No parenting or pediatric group publishes guidance on the signed tablecloth or the thankful pumpkin that we could find. Products are not hands-on tested.

First published October 8, 2026. Last checked October 10, 2026.